Social Interaction
- Key Points of Social Interaction
- Definitions of Social Interaction
- Differential Diagnosis of Social Interaction
- Management of Social Interaction
- Interpersonal intelligence
- Key Points of Interpersonal Intelligence
- Negative Emotional Behaviors
- Key Points of Negative Emotional Behaviors
- Definitions of Negative Emotional Behaviors
- Clinical Guides for Negative Emotional Behaviors(See Clinical Guide
Algorithm)
- Differential Diagnosis of Negative Emotional Behaviors
- Management of Negative Emotional Behaviors
- Co-Morbid Conditions of Negative Emotional Behaviors
- Aggression/Oppositionality
- Key Points of Aggression/Oppositionality
- Definitions of Aggression/Oppositionality
- Clinical Guide for Aggression/Oppositionality (See: Clinical Guide Algorithm)
- Differential Diagnosis of Aggression/Oppositionality
(algorithm)
- Management of Aggression/Oppositionality
- Comorbid Conditions of Aggression/Oppositionality
- Secretive Antisocial Behavior
- Key Points of Secretive Antisocial behavior
- Definitions of Secretive Antisocial behavior
- Clinical Guides for Secretive Antisocial Behaviors (See Clinical Guide Algorithm)
- Differential Diagnosis of Secretive Antisocial Behaviors
- Management of Secretive Antisocial Behaviors
- Comorbid Conditions of Secretive Antisocial behavior
- Tools
- Exposure to Violence Screening Measure
- Citations
- Resources for Parents
-
(Sturner, RA 1997b)
-
(Healthy Steps Interactive Multimedia Training and Resource Kit 2000)
- Age Newborn
- Tracks or moves eyes and even head to follow objects and faces
- Turn their head in response to a voice
- Able to see at 20/200, colors, best at 12-18 inches.
- Hears everything, prefers higher pitched voices and parent's voices
(See Babies have people skills too! Pt)
- Age 1-2 weeks
- Focus on and follow faces
- Respond to a parent's face and voice with tracking and quieting
- Recognize caregivers' smell, voice and appearance
- Age 1-2 months
- May smile at one month, does smile and coo responsively at two months post term.
(See The Smile! pt)
- Focus on and follow faces and brightly colored toys
- Turn their heads in the direction of a parent's voice
- Respond to sound by blinking, crying, quieting, startling, and/or changing respiration
- Age 4 months
- Awake and ready to play; many are sleeping through the night
- Some eating solid food, and mealtime social
- Interacting with and stimulating, showing books and talking
- Demonstrate a range of emotions and smile spontaneously
(See Emotions and Interaction pt)
- Sleep for at least six hours
- Looks around during feeding
- Age 6 months
- Self-comfort
- Self-awareness (See
Hey that's me!)
- Show caution with strangers
- Try to self feed, stare at adults as they eat
- Age 9 months
- Age 12 months
- Participate in social games like peek-a-boo
(See Hello world, it's me! pt)
- Finger feed and drink from a cup
- Imitate household activities
- Express aggression, may bite
- Tantrum when thwarted (See Temper tantrums pt)
- Age 15 months
- Imitate parent actions (sense of self)
- Initiate social games (become the 'hider' in peek-a-boo)
- Begin to use prosocial behaviors (taking turns, comforting others, helping)
(See Brothers and sisters pt)
- Increased clinging and separation issues
- Emerging independence (See Handling the "no's" of toddlerhood
pt)
- Recognize their own unique facial features in the mirror
- Age 18 months
- Use a spoon, a fork, and a cup
- Help dress themselves
- Wash and dry their hands and brush their teeth with help
- Will try to comfort others who seem sad or distressed.
- Increasingly testing limits
- Lose control, hit or bite when frustrated (See Biting pt)
- Play cooperatively for brief sessions (See Sharing and Turn Taking pt)
- Follow a few simple rules
- Need a comfort object (See
I'm Big, But I Still Want My Blankie pt)
- Age 24 months
- Age 30 months
- Feed themselves, dress and undress except for fastenings
- Begin toilet training
- Approach familiar children and play with them
- Age 36 months
- Able to separate for preschool or an organized play group
(See Your child and the world pt)
- Often dealing with new sibling
- Feed self, dress and undress except for fastenings
- Be toilet training
- Approach and play with familiar children
- Have words for feelings and show empathy
- Old methods of discipline may not work anymore
(See Spanking-Is it a good idea? You decide pt)
- Normative Social milestones ages 3 through 18
(Sparrow, SS 1984)
- Age 3 years
- Likes some friends more than others.
- Says "please".
- Can label her own emotions, such as happiness, sadness, fear and anger.
- Starts to recognize personal characteristics of other people.
- Age 4 years
- Shares things without being asked.
- Has favorite television programs and knows the days and channels on which
the programs appear.
- Plays games with simple rules, such as "Go Fish" card game or
"Chutes and Ladders" board game.
- Has a favorite friend, although gender may not matter.
- Capable of obeying school rules.
- Age 5
- Happy for others when they have good luck or success.
- Says "sorry" for inadvertent mistakes.
- Has her own cadre of friends.
- Capable of obeying community rules.
- Age 6
- Can play one or more game involving executive skill or cunning.
- Keeps mouth closed when chewing food.
- Has same sex best friend or "chum".
- Is socially appropriate when meeting strangers.
- Age 7 and 8
- Thinks of thoughtful gestures like making gifts or cards family
member and friends on birthdays or holidays.
- Capable of keeping secrets for more than one day.
- Trustworthy with returning borrowed items to friends and family.
- Knows how to end a conversation politely.
- Age 9
- Aware of time constraints set by parent.
- Doesn't say things that might embarrass or hurt other people.
- When thwarted, can keep anger in check.
- Capable of keeping secrets for as long as required.
- Age 10 and 11
- Capable of using table manners without being asked.
- Socializes at evening school events with peers, when escorted by an adult.
- Capable of weighing pros and cons of a behavior before acting.
- Capable of apologizing and taking responsibility for poor judgment that
may have affected others.
- Age 12 through 14
- Knows and observes birthdays of family and friends.
- More socially aware and capable of starting conversations on topics relevant to others.
- Starts to pursue hobbies.
- Capable of borrowing and repaying money to parent.
- Age 15 through 18+
- Aware of social subtlies such as hints or behavioral cues.
- Enjoys extracurricular sports outside of school.
- Follows up on newsworthy items or interesting topics by consulting television or radio.
- Socializes at evening school events with peers, without adult escort.
- Member of organized club, social group, or service organization.
- Goes on a "date" with one person to party or social gathering.
- May go on "dates" with other couples.
(Berk, LE 2000)
- Ages 3-6: Children start to understand that they have different
thoughts and feelings from other people. However, they still they sometimes misattribute
and confuse the thoughts and feelings of self and other.
- Ages 4-9: Children understand that different perspectives result
from different sources of information. However they still may not be able to "get in the
other person's shoes".
- Ages 7-12: Children are able to take another's point of view or
perspective to more fully understand others thoughts and feelings. The hypothetical
question "How would you feel if _____?" takes on new meaning at this age.
- Ages 10-15: Now children can also understand how a "fly on the wall"
or third party might view interactions of the self and other.
- Ages 14-adult: Children comprehend that societal norms and values
influence third party perspectives.
According to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual for Primary Care (DSM-PC)
Child and Adolescent Version
(
Wolraich, M. (Ed.) 1996)
, the following are the definitions
for Social Interaction and Withdrawal variations and problems:
Because of constitutional and/or psychological factors, children and adolescents will vary in
their ability and desire to interact with other people. Less socially adept or desirous children do not
have a problem as long as it does not interfere with their normal development and activities.
The child's inability and/or desire to interact with people is limited enough to begin to interfere with the child's development and activities.
If abnormalities in social development are noted, such as delayed milestones, social apathy, lack of empathy, excessive shyness, then consider the following disorders:
- Encourage social development by supporting basic competencies
(See Ten things you can do at home pt)
- Encourage self-care for toddlers (See Helping Toddlers Learn Self-Care pt)
- Discuss shyness with parent
- Encourage exploration and understanding of personality traits that affect social interactions:
(See Temperament Questionnaire)
- If ,
help parents and child to accept or .
Be careful not to pathologize a child's shyness unless it significantly interferes with social
functioning.
(Emde, RN 1992)
,
(Schwartz, CE 1999)
,
(Kagan, J 1998)
,
(Fox, NA 2001)
,
(Schmidt, LA 1998)
,
(Henderson, L 1998)
,
- Help parents to see the value in
(Zettergren P 2003)
,
(Wentzel, KR 1995)
- Involve child in physical, intellectual and artistic group
activities such as swimming, crafts, story hour, and play groups. Many activities
are offered free through local libraries or parenting groups and other low-cost
activities are available through community service programs.
- Organize play dates with other same aged children.
- and assist in problem solving.
Ask them what they think is the fair solution.
- Special capacity for recognizing the moods, inclinations, intentions and motivations
of other people (See What is interpersonal intelligence? pt).
- Development begins at birth, primarily though the infant-mother bond.
- Ability to motivate and organize individuals and/or groups of people toward a common goal.
- Negative emotional behaviors such as crying, yelling, irritability, tantrums,
and non-cooperative actions can become pronounced in reaction to stressful life events.
- Does not meet criteria for depression, anxiety disorder or oppositional defiant disorder.
- Many other disorders can mask as a Negative Emotional Behavior Problem.
Systematically rule out other disorders (see Differential Diagnosis).
According to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual for Primary Care (DSM-PC) Child and Adolescent Version
(
Wolraich, M. (Ed.) 1996)
, the following are the definitions for Negative Emotional behavior
Variation and Problem:
Infants and preschool children typically display negative emotional
behaviors when frustrated or irritable. The severity of the behaviors
varies depending on temperament. The degree of difficulty produced by
these behaviors depends, in part, on the skill and understanding of the
caregivers.
Negative emotional behaviors that increase (rather than decrease)
in intensity, despite appropriate caregiver management, and that
begin to interfere with child-adult or peer interactions may be a
problem. These behaviors also constitute a problem when combined
with other behaviors such as hyperactivity/impulsivity, aggression,
and/or depression. However, the severity and frequency of these behaviors
do not meet the criteria for disorder.
- Depression
- Anxiety Disorders
- Aggression/Oppositional Problem, Variation
- Disruptive Behavior Disorder Not Otherwise Specified
- Oppositional Defiant Disorder
- Social skills deficit
- Developmental Delay
- Asperger's Disorder
- Autism
- Learning disorder
- Speech/Language Disorder (e.g., receptive language disorder)
- Sleep debt or disorder which prevents adequate rest
- can manifest as negative emotionality, particularly in children who manifest
traits of high intensity, negative mood or low adaptability.
(use Temperament questionnaire, ).
- Inconsistent or strenuous schedules and (see Sleep DTW)
- Children may act badly if they feel guilty about some real or imagined offense such as a death
and want to be punished.
- Children may also misbehave selectively with adults with whom they have an emotionally
conflicted relationship. (use Family Kinetic Drawing,
Drawing interview)
- Children may act badly to elicit negative responses in relationships where they receive
because the parents are depressed, stressed, too busy or
just not interested.
- Children who are ,
abused, neglected are more likely to display
aggressive behaviors. Also assess childcare for signs of neglect, abuse, inappropriate discipline
and/or aggressive peers. (Use Link to Kemper)
(Jellinek, MS )
- Children learn to deal with their emotions by modeling the way in which emotions are
expressed in their family. Children may also act oppositional to stand up for a parent who seems
to be losing in the marriage or to distract the parents from hostile interactions. A
can stimulate aggressive behavior.
(Jellinek, MS )
- Consider irritable parenting that "sets off" the child due to (Use Link to Kemper)
- Consider predisposing to testing behavior
- Social skills deficits
- Developmental Delay
- Asperger's Disorder
- Autism
- Learning disorder
- Speech/Language Disorder (e.g., receptive language disorder)
-
(Connor, DF 2002)
(pg. 29)
Short outbursts and testing the rules are common developmental occurrences in early childhood and
again in adolescence.
- Prevalence
- Etiology
- Rule out common co-morbid conditions such as , hearing impairment,
learning problems, mood disorders etc. (See Co-morbid Conditions below).
- If aggressive or oppositional behavior appears to be or homicidal, refer immediately for mental health services. Also children who are prone to
"risk taking" may incur harm to themselves or others even when not intending it.
(Connor, DF 2002)
- If a sudden change in behavior occurs or child has a drug using peer group suggest
need for
(see Substance Use DTW).
According to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual for Primary Care (DSM-PC)
Child and Adolescent Version
(
Wolraich, M. (Ed.) 1996)
, the following are the definitions
for Aggressive/Oppositional Behavior Problem and Variation:
Mild opposition with mild negative impact is a normal developmental
variation. Mild opposition may occur several times a day for a short
period. Mild negative impact occurs when no one is hurt, no property
is damaged, and parents do not significantly alter their plans.
In order to assert a growing sense of self, nearly all children
display some amount of aggression, particularly during periods of
rapid developmental transition.
Aggression tends to decline normatively with development.
Aggression is more common in younger children, who lack self-regulatory
skills, than in older children, who internalize familial and societal
standards and learn to use verbal mediation to delay gratification.
Children may shift normatively to verbal opposition with development.
Mild aggression may occur several times per week, with minimal negative impact.
The child will display some of the listed for
oppositional defiant disorder.
The frequency of the opposition occurs enough to be bothersome to parents and supervising
adults, but not often enough to be considered a disorder.
When levels of aggression and hostility interfere with family routines, begin to engender
negative responses from peers or teachers, and/or cause disruption at school, problematic
status is evident.
The negative impact is moderate. People change routines; property begins to be more seriously
damaged. The child will display some of the symptoms listed for conduct disorder but not enough
to warrant the diagnosis of the disorder. However, the behaviors are not sufficiently intense
to qualify for a behavioral disorder.
- A pattern of negativistic, hostile, and defiant behavior lasting
at least 6 months, during which four (or more) of the following are present:
- often loses temper
- often argues with adults
- often actively defies or refuses to comply with adults' requests or rules
- often deliberately annoys people
- often blames others for his or her mistakes or misbehavior
- is often touchy or easily annoyed by others
- is often angry and resentful
- is often spiteful or vindictive
Note: consider a criterion met
only if the behavior occurs more frequently than is
typically observed in individuals of comparable
age and developmental level.
- The disturbance in behavior causes clinically significant impairment in social,
academic, or occupational functioning.
- The behaviors do not occur exclusively during the course of a Psychotic or Mood Disorder.
- Criteria are not met for Conduct Disorder, and, if the individual is age 18 years or older,
criteria are not met for Antisocial Personality Disorder.
This category is for disorders characterized by conduct or oppositional defiant
behaviors that do not meet the criteria for Conduct Disorderor
Oppositional Defiant Disorder. For example, include clinical presentations that do not meet
full criteria either for Oppositional Defiant Disorder or
Conduct Disorder, but
in which there is clinically significant impairment.
- Understand the Extent of the Problem
- Assess frequency
- Look for patterns. Ask about all areas of functioning including mealtimes
bedtime, toileting, peer/sibling interactions, chores, homework, school. This will show a pattern
of parenting, reinforcement of misbehavior, child stress, what is going well, and also direct to
the area for first intervention.
- If behavior is only disturbed in one or two areas of functioning (e.g., homework,
math class) consider a learning/performance weakness (see Learning Disorders and Mental Retardation
in Cognitive Development DTW)
- Assess hearing, if not already done
- Screen for signs of ADHD (present in 60%); if present treat that initially
(see ADHD in Activity/Attention Level DTW).
- If child interview suggests language problem, refer for full evaluation
- Consider and
(see Mental Retardation in Cognitive
Development DTW)
- If irritable mood, consider:
- Sleep debt
- ADHD
- Impaired language comprehension (e.g., hearing problem, Receptive
Language Disorder, or Mixed Receptive-Expressive Language Disorder)
- Mental retardation
- Adjustment disorder
- Disruptive Behavior Disorder NOS
- Mood disorder (Depression, Dysthmia, Bipolar Disorder)
- Psychotic Disorders
- Conduct Disorder, Child-Onset type (symptoms prior to age 10) or
Adolescent-Onset type (no symptoms prior to age 10)
- Substance Abuse
- Aggression/oppositionality in infants and toddlers
- Help parents understand that
is another way for infants to explore but
nonetheless should be discouraged appropriately (see Biting in infancy pt)
-
in the toddler years can be due to frustration, lack of understanding for social
rules or a number of other causes (see Aggressive
behavior and toddlers pt; Time out
pt)
- Toddler oppositionality is a normal part of becoming independent (see
Handling the "no's" of toddlerhood pt)
- Parents with
for the child's abilities or developmental level are less likely to get cooperation from their child.
- Encourage parents to deal with appropriately and explain that tantrums
are a signal that their child is trying to regulate their emotions but needs help
(see Temper tantrums pt).
- Aggression/oppositionality in childhood
- (see Encouraging Strengths pt)
- Child factors:
- Parenting factors
- Dealing with aggression/oppositionality in older children
- Consider diagnosis of Conduct Disorder for children who fail to respond,
escalate in severity of symptoms, or continue to experience problems.
- (e.g., hearing problem, Receptive Language Disorder,
or Mixed Receptive-Expressive Language Disorder)
- Mental retardation
- Learning disorder
-
(Depression, Dysthmia, Bipolar Disorder)
- Psychotic Disorders
- Children may have and misinterpret
events then act aggressively.
- Difficult can manifest as negative emotionality, particularly in children
who manifest traits of high intensity, negative mood or low adaptability. (use Temperament questionnaire,
give caregiver to read)
- Substance Abuse
- Prevelance
- Etiology
- The development of conduct problems and antisocial behavior is thought to be multi-factorial
(American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry 1997)
. Family (e.g., poor parenting, domestic violence or instability, history of mental illness,
aggression, criminality), genetic, and child factors (e.g., temperament,
(Miller-Johnson, S 2002)
- Prognosis
- Assess for self-destructive,
(Connor, DF 2002)
Secretive antisocial behaviors appear at low base rates during early
and middle childhood, with a normative increase toward adolescence.
Mild levels of cheating, lying, and taking of small objects are usually
not of clinical concern during childhood, and some evidence exists that
some experimentation with alcohol and substances in adolescence does not
portend maladjustment.
Secretive antisocial behaviors become problematic when their rates, intensity, and consequences
increase and when parents and caregivers begin to suspect a pattern of lying to hide the offending
actions.
- A repetitive and persistent pattern of behavior in which the
basic rights of others or major age-appropriate societal norms or
rules are violated, as manifested by the presence of three (or more)
of the following criteria in the past 12 months, with at least one
criterion present in the past 6 months.
-
Aggression to people and animals
- often bullies, threatens, or intimidates others
- often initiates physical fights
- has used a weapon that can cause serious physical
harm to others (e.g., a bat, brick, broken bottle, knife, gun)
- has been physically cruel to people
- has been physically cruel to animals
- has stolen while confronting a victim (e.g., mugging, purse snatching, extortion, armed robbery)
- has forced someone into sexual activity
-
Destruction of property
- has deliberately engaged in fire setting with the intention
of causing serious damage
- has deliberately destroyed others' property (other than by fire setting)
-
Deceitfulness or theft
- has broken into someone else's house, building, or car
- often lies to obtain goods or favors or to avoid obligations (i.e.,
"cons" others)
- has stolen items of nontrivial value without confronting victim
(e.g., shoplifting, but without breaking and entering, forgery)
-
Serious violations of rules
- often stays out at night despite parental prohibitions, beginning before
age 13 years
- has run away from home overnight at least twice while living in parental
or parental surrogate home (or once without returning for a lengthy period)
- often truant from school, beginning before age 13 years
- The disturbance in behavior causes clinically significant impairment in social,
academic, or occupational functioning.
- If the individual is age 18 years or older, criteria are not met for Antisocial
Personality Disorder.
-
Specify
type based on age at onset:
-
Childhood-Onset Type: onset at least one criterion characteristic of Conduct Disorder
prior to age 10 years
-
Adolescent- Onset Type: absence of any criteria characteristic of Conduct Disorder
prior to age 10 years
-
Specify
severity:
-
Mild: few if any conduct problems in excess of those required to make the diagnosis
and conduct problems cause only minor harm to others (e.g., lying, truancy, staying out after
dark without permission)
-
Moderate: number of conduct problems and effect on others intermediate between "mild"
and "severe" (e.g., stealing without confronting a victim, vandalism)
-
Severe: may conduct problems in excess of those required to make the diagnosis or
conduct problems cause considerable harm to others (e.g., forced sex, physical cruelty,
use of a weapon, stealing while confronting a victim, breaking and entering)
- Oppositional Defiant Disorder
- ADHD
- Manic episode of Bipolar Disorder
- Adjustment Disorder
- Intermittent Explosive Disorder
- Substance Use Disorder
- Post-traumatic stress disorder
- Dissociative disorders
- Organic brain disorder
- Somatization disorder
- Seizure disorder
- Paraphilias
- Schizophrenia
- In most instances, individual, group and/or family therapy is indicated for the
treatment of antisocial behavior.
- Child factors
- Parent/Family factors
- Help parents set consequences for broken rules that are brief enough to allow earning back
privileges and include new freedoms as incentives (see Principles of
Limit Setting pt)
- Include child in family decision making
(see Family Meeting,
Six Rules for
Decision Making pt)
- Parents may lack reasonable, consistent limits and thus reinforce the behavior
by giving in for a
- Monitor for overtly harsh or .
- Discourage parents from reacting to the child as if he were someone else
)
- Children may act badly to elicit negative responses in relationships where
they receive because the parents are depressed,
stressed, too busy or just not interested.
- Witnessing domestic, family or community violence may promote or reinforce conduct problems
(See above Aggression/Oppositionality, Domestic Violence
DTW, consider administering Exposure to
Violence Screening Measure
(Weist et al., 2002).
- is not sufficient to treat Conduct Disorder. It is most
often used to treat the symptoms of other co-morbid conditions such as depression or ADHD.
(Steiner, H 1997)
- Hospitalization may be indicated if previous treatments have failed and CD symptoms are
intractable and worsening in severity. Immediate in-patient evaluation is warranted if suicidal,
homicidal or self-destructive behavior is on-going or imminent.
- Mood Disorders (Depression, Dysthmia, Bipolar Disorder,
also low self-esteem, suicidal ideation/behavior, homicidal ideation/behavior)
- Anxiety Disorders
- Mental Retardation
- Learning Disorders
- Speech and Language Disorders
- Intermittent Explosive Disorder
- Substance Use Disorder
- Post-traumatic stress disorder
- Dissociative disorders
- Organic brain disorder
- Somatization disorder
- Seizure disorder
- Paraphilias
- Schizophrenia
Grade: _____ Age: _____ Gender: M F Date: ________ Race/Ethnicity: ________
Student: Please answer the following questions about your experiences with violence.
For each violent event, you should report whether: 1) you know of victims; 2) you have witnessed
the activity; 3) you have been a victim in your lifetime. For each violent event, you should
circle a "yes" or a "no" in each of the three areas.
|
Known of Victims? |
Witnessed? |
Been a victim? |
1. Robbery with no weapon |
yes no |
yes no |
yes no |
2. Robbery with a weapon |
yes no |
yes no |
yes no |
3. Assault (beat up) |
yes no |
yes no |
yes no |
4. Assault with a weapon |
yes no |
yes no |
yes no |
5. Rape/sexual abuse w/ weapon |
yes no |
yes no |
yes no |
6. Rape/sexual abuse w/o weapon |
yes no |
yes no |
yes no |
7. Shooting |
yes no |
yes no |
yes no |
8. Stabbing |
yes no |
yes no |
yes no |
9. Murder |
yes no |
yes no |
yes no |
- American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry
(1997).
Practice Parameters for the Assessment and Treatment of Children and Adolescents with Conduct Disorder. .
- AAP Committee on Psychosocial Aspects of Child and Family Health
(1998).
Guidance for Effective Discipline. .
- AAP Committee on Public Education Policy Statement on Media violence
(2001).
. .
- Allmond, BW, Buckman, W, Goman, HF
(1979).
The Family is the Patient: An Approach to Behavioral Pediatrics.
- Barkley, RA
(1997).
Defiant Children: A clinician's manual for assessment and parent training.
- Berk, LE
(2000).
Child Development, Fifth Ed.
- Bushman, BJ, Huesmann, LR
(2001).
Handbook of Children and the Media..
- Canter, L, Canter, M
(1982).
Assertive Discipline for Parents.
- Carey, WB
(1985).
Clinical use of temperament data in pediatrics. .
- Carey, WB, McDevitt, SC
(1995).
Coping with Children's Temperament: A Guide for Professionals.
- Chess, S, Thomas, A
(1986).
Temperament in Clinical Practice.
- Christopherson, ER
(1986).
Anticipatory Guidance on Discipline. .
- Cohen, P, Velez, N, Kohn, M, Schwab-Stone, M, Johnson, J
(1987).
Child psychiatric diagnosis by computer algorithm: Theoretical issues and empirical tests.. .
- Coleman, WL, Howard, BJ
(1995).
Family Focused Behavioral Pediatrics: Clinical Techniques for Primary Care. .
- Coleman, WL, Taylor, EH
(1995).
Family-Focused Pediatrics: Issues, Challenges, and Clinical Methods. .
- Coleman, WL
(1997).
Family-focused pediatrics: Solution-oriented techniques for behavioral problems. .
- Connor, DF
(2002).
Prevalence of Aggression, Antisocial Behavior and Suicide, chapter in Aggression and Antisocial
Behavior in Children and Adolescents.
- Doherty, WJ, Baird, MW
(1983).
Family therapy and Family Medicine: Toward the Primary Care of Families.
- Emde, RN, Plomin, R, Robinson, JA, Corley, R, DeFries, J, Fulker, DW,
et al.
(1992).
Temperament, emotion, and cognition at fourteen months: the MacArthur Longitudinal Twin Study. .
- Faber, A, Mazlish, E
(1980).
How to Talk So Kids Will Listen and Listen So Kids Will Talk.
- Fox, NA, Henderson, HA, Rubin, KH, Calkins, SD, Schmidt, LA
(2001).
Continuity and discontinuity of behavioral inhibition and exuberance: psychophysiological and
behavioral influences across the first four years of life. .
- Gordon, T
(1970).
Parent Effectiveness Training.
- Greene, RW
(1998).
The Explosive Child: A New Approach for Understanding and Parenting Easily Frustrated,
"Chronically Inflexible" Children.
- Healthy Steps Interactive Multimedia Training and Resource Kit
(2000).
.
- Henderson, L, Zimbardo, P
(1998).
Shyness.
- Howard, B.J.
(1996).
Advising Parents on Discipline: What Works. .
- Howard, B. J., Sturner, R. A.
(1994).
Pediatric Behavioral Problems, Monograph Edition No. 186, Home Study Self-Assessment Program.
- Howard, B. J.
(1991).
Discipline in Early Childhood. .
- Howard, BJ
().
The Oppositional Child (lecture).
- Huston, AC, Donnerstein, E, Fairchild, H, et al
(1992).
Big World, Small Screen: The Role of Television in American Society.
- Hyman, LA
(1995).
Corporal Punishment, Psychological Maltreatment, Violence, and Punitiveness in America: Research Advocacy,
and Public Policy. .
- Jellinek, MS
().
Bright Futures in Practice, Mental Health (2002).
- Kagan, J, Snidman, N, Arcus, D
(1998).
Childhood derivatives of high and low reactivity in infancy. .
- Kashani JH, Beck, NC, Hoeper, EW, Fallanhi, C, Corcoran, CM, McAllistair, JA,
et al.
().
Psychiatric disorders in a community sample of adolescents. .
- Kazdin, AE
(1985).
Treatment for antisocial behaviors in children and adolescents.
- Maternal and Child Health Bureau
(2002).
Healthy Start, Grow Smart: Your Newborn.
- Loeber, R
(1991).
Antisocial behavior: more enduring than changeable? Special section:
longitudinal research. .
- McDaniel, S, Campbell, TL, Seaburn, DB
(1990).
Family-Oriented Primary Care: A Manual for Medical Providers.
- Miller-Johnson, S, Coie, JD, Maumary-Gremaud, A, Bierman, K
(2002).
Conduct Problems Prevention Research Group. Peer rejection and aggression and early starter
models of conduct disorder. .
- Paik, H, Comstock, G
(1994).
The effects of television violence on antisocial behavior: a meta-analysis. .
- Patterson, GR, Forgatch, M
(1975).
Family Living Series Part 1 (5 cassette tapes to be used with Living with Children).
- Patterson, GR, Forgatch, M
(1976).
Family Living Series Part 2 (3 cassette tapes to be used with Living with Children).
- Patterson, GR
(1976).
Living with Children, New Methods for Parents and Teachers.
- Patterson, GR, DeBarshe, BD, Ramsey, E
(1989).
a developmental perspective. on antisocial behavior.. .
- Phelan, TW
(1996).
1,2,3 Magic. Second edition.
- Plomin, R, Nitz, K, Rowe, DC
(1990).
Handbook of developmental psychopathology.
- Schmidt, LA, Fox, NA
(1998).
Fear-potentiated startle responses in temperamentally different human infants. .
- Schwartz, CE, Snidman, N, Kagan, J
(1999).
Adolescent social anxiety as an outcome of inhibited temperament in childhood. .
- Sheeber, L. B., McDevitt, S. C.
(1989).
Handbook of Parent Training.
- Sparrow, SS, Balla, DA, Cicchetti, D
(1984).
Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales, Interview Edition, Survey Form.
- Steiner, H, Dunne, J
(1997).
Summary of the practice parameters for the assessment and treatment of children
and adolescents with conduct disorder. .
- Straus, MA
(1994).
Beating the Devil Out of Them, Corporal Punishment in American Families.
- Sturner, RA, Howard, BJ
(1997b).
Preschool Development II: Psychosocial/Behavioral Development. .
- Sheeber, L. B., McDevitt, S. C.
(1989).
Handbook of Parent Training.
- Varni, JW, Christopherson ER
(1990).
Behavioral Treatment in Pediatrics. .
- Webster-Stratton, C, Kolpacoff, M, Hollinsworth, T
(1989).
The Long-Term Effectiveness and Clinical Significance of Three Cost-Effective Training Programs
for Families with Conduct Problem Children. .
- Wentzel, KR, Asher, SR
(1995).
The academic lives of neglected, rejected, popular, and controversial children. .
- Wissow, LS, Roter, DR
(1994).
Toward Effective Discussion of Discipline and Corporal Punishment During Primary Care Visits:
Findings from Studies of Doctor-Patient Interaction. .
- Yokota, F, Thompson, KM
(2000).
Violence in G-rated animated films. .
- Zettergren P
(2003).
School adjustment in adolescence for previously rejected, average and popular children. .
- American Psychiatric Association
(1994).
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders.
- Wolraich, M. (Ed.)
(1996).
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual for Primary Care (DSM-PC): Child and Adolescent Version.
Carey WB, with Jablow M. 1997. Understanding Your Child's Temperament. New York: MacMillian.
Turecki, S., The Difficult Child. Bantam Books, 2000.
Greenspan, S. I., The Challenging Child. Reading, Mass.: Perseus Books, 1995.
Benson, P.L. All Kids Are Our Kids: What Communities Must Do To Raise Caring And
Responsible Children and Adolescents. Jossey-Bass, 1997.
Shure, M. Raising a Thinking Child: Help Your Young Child To Resolve Everyday
Conflicts and Get Along With Others: The "I Can Problem Solve" Program. Pocket Books, 1996.
Shure, M. Raising a Thinking Preteen. Henry Holt, 2000.
Comments
To find the comment in-context, please follow the provided links.
- Overview of Infant Social Development: 1)In infancy, psychosocial development occurs almost entirely in the context of the family and other close caregivers. From birth to 12 months, it is through responsive interactions with parents and a few other special caregivers that infants develop a sense of a safe, interesting, and orderly world. Learning that they can depend on being cared for and being kept safe helps infants build both a sense of trust in their ability to communicate their needs and wants and a sense of security that influences their inclination to explore. 2) Exploration takes center stage as infants become more mobile. It is important for parents to remember that infants at this stage practice independence but very much need trusted adults as a secure base of support. During the first year, children make use of new physical, cognitive, social, and emotional abilities and the connections among them to discriminate between familiar and unfamiliar people. Almost all infants during this period show stranger anxiety toward unfamiliar people. 3) The period from 12-36 months is filled with exploration, discovery, and determination to find meaning and relationships in events, objects, and words. At about 18 months of age, the focus shifts to issues of identity, autonomy, power, and control. 4) As part of their social development, toddlers begin to move away from their parents, but they also learn now to maintain and reestablish the relationship by coming back. Toddlers know that if they run away, parents, will come and swoop them up. But as children get father away from their secure base, or if parents or caregivers are not available for refueling, the child will engage in what Margaret Mahler refers to as "wooing." In cases in which toddlers are not sure that their parents will be there, they use up all their energy "wooing" instead of exploring new territory. 5) By two years of age, the task of forming an attachment to a primary caregiver is largely accomplished, and the toddler's task is to draw on that attachment to function independently. The average 3-year-old can separate easily from parents and go to known adults; however, there is great variability, related largely to temperament. Children with difficult attachment histories may react to separation with either clinginess and fear or indiscriminate sociability.
- Trigger Questions: 1) How does _____ act around family members? 2) How does she/he react to strangers? 3) How is child care (preschool, kindergarten) going? (as related to separation) 4) How do you deal with temper tantrums? 5) What do you and your partner enjoy most about _____? 6) What seems to be most difficult?
- Normative Social Milestones Through Age 3: Adapted from Healthy Steps Interactive Multimedia Training and Resource Kit (2000). Independent Production Fund; Toby Levine Communications, Inc.; and the Boston University School of Medicine, Department of Pediatrics
- Perspective taking: Selman Stages of Perspective Taking
- Self-Awareness: Identifying one's thoughts, feelings, and strengths, and recognizing how they influence one's choices and actions.
- Social Awareness: Identifying and understanding the thoughts and feelings of others, respecting their rights, and appreciating diversity.
- Self-Management: Establishing and working toward short- and long-term goals, and handling emotions so that they facilitate rather than interfere with the task at hand.
- Responsible Decision Making: Generating, implementing, and evaluating positive and informed solutions to problems, and assuming responsibility for personal decisions and behaviors.
- Relationship Skills: Communication, listening, and negotiation skills to establish and maintain healthy and rewarding connections with individuals and groups.
- Key Points: Acquiring self-care skills is a major area of mastery which symbolizes growing independence and self control to the child.
-
Management: 1) Advise parents to begin predictable fun routines such as brushing teeth and hand washing at a young age, to reduce resistance, facilitate learning, and teach the ability to tolerate necessary discomfort. 2) Encourage parents to use self-care as an opportunity for the child to make choices (within those acceptable to the family) and to act independently, e.g., choosing clothing, bathing themselves. Remind parents that children need extra time and chances to make mistakes during this learning process. Small steps towards success should be praised. 3) Anticipate regressions in self care at times of stress or transition and encourage the family to accept these and to assist the child rather than criticizing her. 4) Consider that temper tantrums during self-care may point to a weakness in skills that needs to be evaluated or suggest too much pressure or restriction by parents. 5) For children with fine-motor delays or deficits: Suggest accommodations such as loose-fitting clothing, angled spoons, or other adaptive equipment so that children can maximally care for themselves. Occupational therapists can advise on specific equipment and provide teaching. 6) Parents who are having trouble allowing their child to mature may be underestimating their child's abilities. Parenting groups or classes, Mothers Morning Out, and other opportunities to talk with parents of similar age children can help with developing realistic goals. Discuss the risk of oppositional behavior resulting from parental interference in self-care. 7) Discuss self-care routines as "transitions"
- Helping toddlers get dressed without a battle: 1) Choose clothing that is easy to put on (Sweatpants and leggings, clothing with large arm and neck holes and few fasteners, Velcro) 2) Give toddlers limited choices (two or three acceptable outfits chosen by parent) This gives children some control and may prevent battles. 3) Allow extra time 4) Prepare the toddler in advance 5) Use distraction (singing, talking, etc.) or make dressing a game 6) Praise for compliance 7) Discuss "getting dressed" as a transition
- smooth transitions: Definition of transitions: the time periods in which a parent moves the child's focus from playing to what the parent needs him or her to do 1) Ask the parent which are the hardest transitions for the parent and child. 2) Some of the hardest transitions may include: a) Starting the day after awakening b) Getting him or her dressed c) Sitting down for mealtime d) Getting the child into the car e) Starting bath time f) Getting the child into bed at nap or night 3) Suggest ways to the parent to better manage transitions: a) Give the child enough control so that the child feels as if she or he can do it herself or himself. b) Prepare the child and anticipate concerns so that she or he will know what to expect. c) Give the child extra time and slow down. When the child senses that he or she is being rushed, the child may resist the change and transition. d) Give the child choices so the child feels as if he or she has more control of the situation. e) Make it a game and playful in order to peak the child's interest. A related song during the transition can be both entertaining and enticing. f) Daily routines make it easier for the child to anticipate what is next. g) Rewards for a smooth transition are positive reinforcers and can be as simple as several extra minutes of the parent reading a bedtime story. h) Discourage threats (including those of separation) and punishment.
- Shyness and introversion: Shy individuals avoid social contact and sometimes fear it; introverts simply prefer being alone over social activities and do not have trouble interacting and socializing with others as many shy people experience.
- shy: Shyness, or "behavioral inhibition to the unfamiliar", evidences significant heritablity. Research has shown that having an inhibited behavioral style as early as age 2 years may predispose one to social anxiety in adolescence. Also inhibition has been shown to manifest as early as 4-months of age and to be moderately stable over the course of development. 1) Shyness may be associated with low threshold for arousal in forebrain limbic areas. 2) Among adults about 40% describe themselves as shy to such a degree that it interferes with daily life. Symptoms of shyness may include, but are not limited to, self-consciousness, embarrassment interacting with others, avoidance of social situations, dry mouth, racing heart, and speech idiosyncrasies or dysfluencies, usually all when presented with the possibility or reality of social interaction. More serious symptoms may indicate an anxiety disorder.
- seek ways to overcome: Given the value modern society places on being out-going, treatments geared primarily for adolescents and adults are available for "shyness". Treatment modalities include but are not limited to social skills training, flooding, in-vivo exposure, assertiveness training, self-concept restructuring.
- fostering healthy peer relations: Children who are rejected by peers have more academic and behavioral problems while children who are neglected by peers appear to actually quite well academically. For children who are already "at-risk", healthy peer relations and the social support they imbue may serve as a protective buffer that shields the child from the otherwise damaging effects of poverty, violence, family mental illness and other environmental or familial risk factors.
- Guide child
through social conflicts: Usually by age 4 children are able to do some problem solving on their own (at least partially). With guidance they will become more skilled.
- Capacity for intrapersonal intelligence is localized in the frontal lobes.: Damage to this area can result in severe or acute impairment of intrapersonal and/or interpersonal knowledge and functioning. Yet even with severe brain injury in the frontal lobes, other forms of intelligence may remain intact. The effect is similar in some developmental disorders, such as autism spectrum disorders, where the capacity for making and maintaining interpersonal relationships is severely impaired, but other intelligences are functional or even enhanced.
- Trigger questions: 1)How does s/he seem to feel when acting badly? When punished? 2) How much time do you have with him/her alone each day? How about your partner? 3) (To child) Would you say you are a good boy or a bad boy? 4) (To child) What do your parents do when you do something bad? What do you think they should do? 5) (To child) Do you get enough time alone with your mom? Dad?
- Temperament: Ask parents who the child "takes after" to elicit a description of temperament and parental projections. Check the child adjective checklist to get a sense of the parent's perception of the child's temperament or have the parents fill out a standard temperament questionnaire.
- give
caregiver book to read: Understanding Your Child's Temperament, by William B. Carey, Martha M. Jablow, C. Everett Koop, 1997, Macmillan General Reference.
- lack of sleep: makes children vulnerable to aggressive behaviors due to the fact that they are often tired, hungry, or stressed by irregular, unusual demands.
- inadequate attention: Children will do anything to engage caregivers including the opposite of what is asked.
- witness to violence: Children viewing violence may model after it. Children with a traumatic experience may feel guilty and act up to elicit punishment. Family members experiencing trauma may change their parenting. Trigger questions to ask if Age = Early Childhood 1) Have you ever been worried that someone was going to hurt your child? 2) Has your child ever been abused? 3) Do you feel safe in your neighborhood? Trigger questions to ask if age = Middle childhood 1) Have you ever been worried that someone was going to hurt your child? 2) Has your child ever been abused? 3) (To child) Has anyone tried to harm you physically? 4) (To child)Has anyone touched you in a way you didn't like? 5) Do you feel safe in your neighborhood? Does Johnny feel safe? Adapted from: Jellinek MS. Bright Futures in Practice, Mental Health (2002). Georgetown University: National Center for Education in Maternal and Child Health.
- tense family
atmosphere: Trigger Questions: 1) How are things going in your family? 2) How are things with your marriage? 3) How are things sexually? 4) (To child)How do people get along at your house? Adapted from: Jellinek MS. Bright Futures in Practice, Mental Health (2002). Georgetown University: National Center for Education in Maternal and Child Health.
- depressed or stressed
caregiver.: Caregivers who are depressed, overburdened or under stress may have a low threshold for reacting to negative emotions in their children or may react irritably to normal behavior. Consider a questionnaire about perceived family stressors and their impact on family functioning.
- insecure attachment: Securely attached children have more cooperative behavior and better peer relationships. Insecure attachment predisposes to suspicion of others and preemptive aggression.
- Aggression can be a part of normal development.: "Observational studies (Holmberg, 1977) indicate that approximately 50% of the social interchanges between children 12-18 months of age in a nursery school setting can be viewed as disruptive or conflictual. By age 2.5 years, the proportion of conflicted social interchanges decreases to 20%.".
- Rates: DSM-IV, American Psychiatric Association, 1994.
- Combination of genetic, child, familial and environmental factors.: 1) Some evidence for heritability exists although these traits are by no means immutable. 2) Family factors such as inconsistent schedules, emotionally conflicted relationships and poor parenting may contribute. A learned pattern of coercive aggression among children whose parents are dismissive, overly hostile, negative and inconsistent is now widely accepted. In essence, the child who acts aggressively does so because it is the one way he has learned to get attention from parents who otherwise ignore or are hostile with him. The child's aggressive behavior escalates when reinforced. Parents can reinforce by giving in with attention, even if negative, overly harsh punishment, or by yielding to the child's demands. 3) Other factors contributing to the development and stability of aggression in childhood are rejection by peers early in grade school, media violence, and social skills deficits.
- Can be a precursor of Conduct Disorder in adolescence.: Two developmental pathways have been proposed: the early starter and late starter. Early starters develop Oppositional Defiant Disorder early in the preschool years and steadily progress to more serious antisocial behavior in adolescence. Late starters have normal early childhoods and engage in antisocial behavior beginning in adolescence. The prognosis is much more favorable for late starters.
- ADHD: Up to 60% of children with oppositional behavior may have ADHD.
- self-destructive,
suicidal: Suicide accounts for 12% of mortality among adolescents in the US. Older adolescents (15-19 years) have a rate of suicide that is 8 times higher than younger adolescents (10-14 years).
- substance misuse evaluation: 1.Perform a physical examination looking for signs of drug abuse. 2. Consider screening urine or blood for substances. 3. See the Substance Abuse section.
- symptoms: (1)often loses temper (2) often argues with adults (3) often actively defies or refuses to comply with adults' requests or rules (4) often deliberately annoys people (5) often blames others for his or her mistakes or misbehavior (6) is often touchy or easily annoyed by others (7) is often angry and resentful (8) is often spiteful or vindictive
- Elicit specific examples of
misbehavior: Examples will help determine parent management, which may be appropriate or may promote the problem. Trigger questions: 1) Can you recall a recent example -what did you do about it? 20 What have you done so far to correct the problem?
- Assess intensity: Trigger Question: How bad goes it get?
- Assess interference with family
functioning.: Trigger Questions: 1) What is it like for you at home? 2) Has this behavior problem changed your daily life?
- cognitive delay: Check the results of the START developmental screening or perform an academic screen. 1) Refer for developmental evaluation if you can't rule out delay 2) Child Find evaluation (early intervention age 3-5) 3) Psychoeducational testing at school
- adjust parenting strategies appropriately for mental
age: 1) Consider whether expectations are appropriate for the child's abilities. 2) Determine if oppositional only in situations which stress their abilities 3) Consider transfer to a less demanding setting. 4) Appropriate special education 5) Coach parents about expectations for the child's mental age. 6) Suggest that parents observe other children of that mental age (e.g., on playground) or read about normal skills for that mental age (see Gesell) to set new expectations.
- sleep debt: Fatigued children are often irritable. School aged children need 9.5 or more good quality sleep. If sleep is disrupted or inadequate, treat that. 1) Explain the need for structure and consistency 2) Children who are overtired or overstressed have a hard time controlling their emotions. 3) Assess total sleep and sleep quality 4) Choose one particularly problematic area and work out a schedule 5) See the family back within a week or two to make adjustments as necessary. 6) Refer to the handouts on sleep routine, toilet training challenges, helping your child master self care, and eating as appropriate
- mood disorders: 1) Assess suicidality 2) Make prompt mental health referral. 3) Continue intermittent visits to monitor progress/compliance and serve as a support person/ care coordinator.
- Asperger's disorder, Autism or Child Disintegrative Disorder: These Pervasive Developmental Disorders are typically, but not exclusively, diagnosed by the preschool years.
- infant biting: Biting in infancy can be simply another way for babies to experiment with putting things in their mouths. Help parents to understand this, and to manage infant biting by: 1) Staying calm but giving a clear and strong message of disapproval followed by a 15 second "time out" in which the baby is put down 2) Clarifying those times when infants are biting due to hunger or teething 3) Making sure parents are not teaching infants not to bite by biting back. 4) Monitoring to make sure that the child is not being hurt by another child or caregiver 5) Monitoring for tension in the home, which may increase infant biting
- Biting: Biting and other forms of aggression can be common during the toddler years, but are upsetting to parents, children, and victims. Toddler aggression can result from frustration at lack of verbal means of expression, lack of understanding of social rules, curiosity, boredom, anxiety, or teething. Help parents to determine the reason their child is being aggressive (e.g. excitement, anger, stress, imitating another child). The following can help to decrease toddler aggression: 1) Remaining calm, but separating biter and victim. Offer comfort to the victim to minimize attention to the biter. 2) Giving a clear and strong message of disapproval, offering an explanation of how the child's aggression hurts another child 3) Time out 4) Helping the child develop the words to express his feelings of anger or frustration 5) Helping the child develop other ways to vent anger or frustration (e.g. pounding a pillow) 6) Offer praise for cooperation 7) Make sure parents are not biting back to teach the child what it feels like 8) Monitor for cognitive/language delays that may increase frustration and therefore aggression 9) Monitor for cases in which the child is being hurt by other children or caregivers 10) Ask about daycare and whether caregivers give "positive attention" for good behavior and self-control 11) Monitor for excessive tension/yelling in the home, which may increase toddler aggression. 12) Ask about the amount of time the toddler spends with more advanced children. Too much time with more advanced children may overwhelm the child and increase his or her aggression.
- unreasonable expectations: Ask parents about their child's level of self care (i.e. toileting, eating, dressing, homework) and at what age they expect a child to perform these tasks independently. Trigger questions to ask: 1) How is Johnny's doing with independence in toileting, dressing, eating, homework, etc....? 2) At what age do you expect him to be independent at these tasks?
- tantrums: 1) Tantrums represent the child's emotions going beyond their control. 2) Tantrums or "falling out" spells are nearly universal during toddlerhood and preschool. Children unable to tantrum may be insecure in their relationships although children of easy temperament may not tantrum. 3) Tantrums may start as early as 9 months but peak between 15-36 months with another peak at age 6 years. 4) Developmental gaps predispose to tantrums through frustration. Expressive language delay and fine motor delays are the most common precipitants. 5) Tantrums are often viewed as manipulative by parents even when they don't start out to be. However, tantrums often result in caregivers giving the child what they wanted quickly resulting in a manipulative habit (reinforcement). 6) Tantrums are more likely when the child is sleep deprived, at a tired time, hungry, needing attention or stressed. This can be helped by routines and adequate sleep. 7) Temperamentally intense or "difficult" children have more tantrums than "easy" children. 8) Some parents are better at easing children through transitions than others thus avoiding tantrums. Other parents seem to gain satisfaction on an unconscious level by frustrating their child. This is likely to be related to their own parents having done this to them during child rearing (See Social History) or a negative perception of this child (see adjective checklist results). Some caregivers covertly reinforce tantrums by giving extra attention or by punishing the child in the context of relatively low attention otherwise. 9) Inconsistency among caregivers can confuse and frustrate the child increasing tantrums. Consistency within the practices of an individual caregiver is more important, however, and inter-caregivers disputes are more damaging than inconsistency from the child's point of view. 10) Children with very severe tantrums may have a mental health disorder, especially Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder or a Mood Disorder.
- Trigger questions: 1)"How are tantrums?" 2) "What do you do when s/he has a tantrum?" 3) "What does his/her father (other caregivers) do about tantrums?" 4) "How bad does it get?" 5) "How does that make you feel?" 6) "When have you felt that way before sometime in your life?" 7) "What do you think it means when s/he has a tantrum?" 8) "Give me an example of a tantrum s/he has had recently." 9) "Who does s/he take after?"
- Normal tantrums: Anticipate the onset of tantrums by 12 months and check parental philosophy to avoid punishment but also avoid reinforcement through giving in. 1) Tantrums resulting in aggression should be managed for the aggression i.e. time out. 2) Educate parents about the importance of gradually gaining ability to tolerate frustration in little doses during toddlerhood for future adult functioning. 3) Caregivers can avoid tantrums by facilitating the child getting what they want but need to do this quickly before a tantrum starts to avoid reinforcement. Have them decide quickly what is acceptable for the child to have or do and provide it promptly.
- Severe tantrums: 1) Elicit a specific example of a tantrum and what the parent did about it. Look for the "A"ntecedants (circumstances, preceding actions by others)- "B"ehavior (what the child did) and "C"onsequences (what the caregiver did, or the result for the child) to analyze potential reinforcers. If reinforcement seems to be the source- coach on giving adequate attention when the child is doing well and distracting or ignoring when tantrums start. 2) Assure adequate sleep, food, and routines 3) Check developmental skills for gaps (See developmental items of Babybook). Perform a developmental assessment especially for fine motor and language skills and refer for habilitation if needed. 4) If parents have trouble tolerating their child's frustration, examine the reasons usually stemming from the parent's past, marital discord over child management, or vulnerable child syndrome. 5) If parents are overtly frustrating the child- ask about their own parents' child rearing and their perception of this child. 6) Coach on consistency within the practices of an individual caregiver and avoiding interference between caregivers. Tell them to practice "Whoever starts, finishes". 7) Check on quality of other childcare for sources of upset or frustration e.g. discipline, overwhelmed by older peers, neglect. If this is a major factor, suggest changing daycare. Consider a smaller family day care setting with a larger range in ages of children. Consider mental health disorders e.g. ADHD, mood disorders if the child is not functioning well, the family is very distressed, or there are other symptoms suggestive.
- Encourage Strengths: 1) Community service is source of skill building for child and families (e.g., Habitat for Humanity, soup kitchens, Candy Stripers, Salvation Army, church group activities). 2) Encourage extra curricular activities even when not doing well academically to help them to bond to the school or other social structure, stay motivated, and develop self esteem. 3) In some cases, the child should be required to participate. 4) Refer children to mentors for talents they have or interest areas even if their abilities are unknown. See resources by activity area. 5) Community service is source of skill building for child and families (e.g., Habitat for Humanity, soup kitchens, Candy Stripers, Salvation Army, church group activities).
- social skills training intervention: This type of program will train children to improve social skills (empathy, listening, ascribing attributions) and problem-solving (resolving conflict, communication, understanding consequences). Comprehensive social skills programs that involve parents, are specifically geared for the age of the child, and focus on reducing aggression will be most effective.
- If childcare or school setting is deficient: 1) Encourage parents to drop in at the day care to observe the quality of care 2) If attention to their child is inadequate, they may try to coach day care to do better 3) If nothing improves in 3 weeks or if family is dissatisfied, recommend new quality child care or school
- If child is reacting to family event such as divorce, death or marital discord,
have parents assure children it is not their fault: Some children feel that their bad behavior has lead to divorce, family strife, or other poor outcome. Directly tell child "It is not your fault" and coach child to tell themselves that it is not his/her fault. Tell parents this may be the case and that they should also reassure child.
- exposure to violence: Discuss the importance of limiting the child's exposure to violence via TV and video games. By the age of 18 most kids have been exposed to hundreds of thousands of acts of violence on television. Also a recent study found that all children's animated movies made from 1936 through 1999 contained violent acts.
- Too lax: 1) Encourage avoiding rescuing child too quickly from difficulties to build competence. 2) Praise child for strength and resilience to accept failures and mistakes gracefully and continuing to try. 3) Adults model tolerance for their own mistakes. 4) Advise parental noninterference to allow children to solve interactional problems 5) Role play with child generating solutions and likely outcomes, especially possible impacts upon relationships. 6) Help parent detect a difference between the current situation and the past one (trigger) to remind to react differently. 7) Consider "nchor" (e.g., touch, thought, or phrase to remind that they and child are safe now). 8) Parents unable to make progress need mental health referral.
- Too strict limits: 1) Determine discipline philosophy and strategies for different child behaviors. 2) Ask child (3 and over): What happens when you do __? What do your parents do? What do you think about that? 3) Interpret pleasure in breaking rules as learning not criminality but that explanation and consequences are still needed. 4) Teach to explain rules calmly, require a consequence, and increase monitoring. 5) Educate in smaller consequences along with reasons. 6) Handout: Principles of limit setting 7) Advise to respond to aggression promptly, calmly and not excessively from an early age, showing appropriate facial disapproval (e.g., time out, remove an object) 8) Assure that negative behavior is not the main way of getting attention. 9) Educate that misbehaviors are usually repeated even when appropriate consequences are being given. 11) Handout: Time out 12) Explore how parents interact around managing the child's behavior looking for interference or undermining. This usually works best when all principal caregivers are included in the discussions 13) Explore caregivers' own experiences as children (How would your parents have handled this?) and how they developed their limits (What did you decide about that?). 14) Work with them to understand the relationship between their parenting practices and the child's behavior and to find a middle ground 15) Pick one behavioral scenario to do differently and come to agreement on each parents' actions for it. Signing a contract may be needed. 16) Schedule a follow up in 2-3 weeks by phone or in person. 17) Handout: Principles of Limit Setting handout.
- Inconsistent management: Inconsistency is confusing and tends to make testing by the child worse. Advise parents to pick a few key behaviors, decide on the way they want to handle these, and stick to the plan for at least 3 weeks. They should notice, after an initial period of increased testing, a decreased struggle around these. This will motivate them to try a few more. If parents disagree, at least have them stick to their own ideas and not interfere or comment openly about the way the other parent handles things. A good rule is "Whoever starts (to handle the situation), finishes". If one parent spanks and the other doesn't approve, see management of spanking section.
- Inappropriate expectations: 1) Ask at what age they expect a child to perform these tasks. 2) Consider Vineland Test of Adaptive Functioning. 3) Suggest parenting groups, Mothers Morning Out 4) Discuss the disadvantages of oppositional or passive behavior that may result. 5) Consider factors predisposing to the Vulnerable Child Syndrome. 6) Help parents differentiate high expectations from damaging pressure 7) Explain the risks of: child feeling like a failure; futile efforts to please being replaced by resistance, resentment, and damaged self esteem. 8) Help design at least one appropriate expectation 9) Help identify a strength on which to build. See strengths questionnaire, adjective questionnaire. 10) Assure challenges in the major developmental domains (e.g., chores for responsibility; independence for social development; tasks requiring some effort for motor and cognitive abilities; talking and being listening to at family meals for language skills). 11) Consider a developmental screen (e.g., DDST-R) to point to lack of opportunity or challenge to develop.
- Overt or covert
reinforcement of misbehavior: 1) Elicit examples of response to tantrum or aggressive behaviors 2) Determine if parents view misbehavior as vigor or means to solving problems. 3) Explain the connection of passive reactions to persist opposition/aggression. 4) Obtain agreement for noninterference: "Whoever starts, finishes" 5) Discuss what each parent "gets out of" the way they handle the behavior and the "costs" 6) Ask how they would like things to be 6 months from now. 7) Prescribe private parental debriefing" daily to review and renegotiate. 8) Teach "one request and then move" and use of Time out. See Principles of limit setting 9) Refer parents with a lot of anger to parent groups provided by Protective Services, Parents Anonymous, Children with Hyperactivity and Attention Deficit Disorder (CHADD), Alcoholics Anonymous or Alanon, or mental health providers. See Resource list. 10) Refer parents who can't agree on discipline for further counseling.
- Parental Depression: 1) Emphasize that parents take care of themselves for the child's sake. Refer to appropriate services. 2) Take a history of family health and treatments to determine if they are appropriate. 3) Recommend quality child care or school if the parents can't provide a safe and stimulating environment. 4) Get written permission and communicate with health, mental health and childcare providers so that services can be coordinated. 5) Prescribe "50 touches per day" to increase indications of positive regard. 6) Prescribe Special Time
- work stress: 1) Recommend parent groups, babysitting cooperatives, Mothers Morning Out, Tot Gymnastics as ways to meet potential social supports. 2) Encourage church or synagogue or temple membership. 3) Suggest cheap young sitter so parent can have "alone time" in the house. 4) Encourage regular dates for the parents to relieve stress. 5) Suggest a few extra minutes for themselves before picking up from day care. 6) Suggest the sitters at spa or gym to simultaneously exercise and get a break. 7) If family discord is preventing relatives from being supportive, suggest family counseling. 8) Refer to pastoral counseling as an alternative
- Domestic violence: 1) Prevalence: Approximately 4 million American women experience a serious assault by an intimate partner during any single year, exposing an estimated 3.3 million children to family violence annually. Few clinicians identify domestic violence, although they may be the only professionals seeing the affected families. 2) Effects on children: Children exposed to domestic conflict suffer the psychological trauma of witnessing battering, which can lead to learning difficulties and problems in social relationships. Witnessing violence affects the way children view the world and their place in it. They come to see the world as a dangerous and unpredictable place. This fear may limit their exploration of their environment, which is the key to learning in childhood. They also may suffer psychological trauma and develop multiple problems including aggressive b ehavior as well as depression, low self-esteem and posttraumatic stress disorder.
- Corporal punishment: Educate in the use of non-corporal punishment to avoid the side effects of fostering and modeling aggression.
- Marital discord: 1) Refer for marital counseling or mediation 2) Emphasize to avoid arguments in front of children 3) Teach active listening skills to encourage verbalization of emotions 4) Encourage modeling expression of affection, concern, caring 5) Prescribe "50 touches a day" to aid conveying positive regard 6) Prescribe Special Time 7) Model and teach having children self evaluate strengths and successes 8) Refer to parent groups provided by Protective Services, Parents Anonymous, Alcoholics Anonymous or Alanon, or mental health providers.
- Insecure attachment: 1) Discuss that a child who feels adults believe in her will begin to believe in herself. 2) Help parents understand that higher self esteem is positively related to closeness with parents and negatively related to parental punitiveness and control 3) Encourage parents to allow their child to make decisions 4) Discuss that parents need to guide children to show them what is wrong, dangerous, unacceptable, or in poor taste. 5) When children make mistakes parents need to correct in a loving way, not personally attack, and avoid scolding or embarrassing a child in front of friends. 6) Encourage parents to support their child's relationships with other adults-extended family members, neighbors, teachers, religious leaders, and coaches.
- History of receiving poor parenting: 1) Help parent detect a difference between the current situation and the past one (trigger) to remind to react differently. 2) Consider "anchor" (e.g., touch, thought, or phrase to remind that they and child are safe now) 3) Congratulate on overcoming and clarify that parenting reflexes are based on past 4) Have parents notice and thank themselves when they stop maladaptive responses earlier 5) Consider a "trigger" to remind themselves of how they want to act 6) Create nonverbal signal for couples to use if one is losing control for other to take over 7) Teach time out early explaining that they "will never have to spank" 8) Teach to explain rules calmly, require a consequence, and increase monitoring. 9) Educate in smaller consequences along with reasons. 10) Advise to respond to aggression promptly, calmly and not excessively from an early age, showing appropriate facial disapproval (e.g., time out, remove an object) 11) Assure that negative behavior is not the main way of getting attention. 12) Parents unable to make progress need mental health referral.
- Prejudiced against this child: 1) Have the parent keep a diary of incidents and exactly what thoughts and feelings they had just before and just after each incident 2) Have the parent pretend they are someone else when they begin with the inappropriate pattern. 3) Encourage parents to resolve past conflicted relationships either in reality or just in their minds so that "it no longer has power over their parenting". 4) Refer for mental health counseling of the parent or the child if these strategies do not change the pattern.
- risk taking: 1) If self destructive, refer immediately for mental health services. 2) Reframe such behavior as an emergency for the parent since their lack of concern is likely to have been part of the escalation of the child's actions. 3) If mainly group risk taking, end or limit. This reason should be made explicit so child will know it is done out of caring. 4) See Six Rules for Decision Making parent text 5) A child who does not understand risk may have Mental Retardation, Asperger's Syndrome, or Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder.
- Other general Acute Medical
Conditions: Any acute illness requiring hospitalization (Any severe injury, Sickle cell disease, esp. during crises, Cystic fibrosis, Diabetes Mellitus, Celiac Disease). Parental expectations for behavior of ill children are often inconsistent. Child may also be more irritable due to discomfort, fatigue, medications, frustration, etc.
- ADHD: Up to 60% of children with oppositional behavior may have ADHD. Consider using a standard screening questionnaire, such as the Connors Rating Scale.
- Impaired language comprehension: Even mildly hearing impaired children may cover up their lack of comprehension by general opposition. Because they are often frustrated by their inability to express their needs, children with developmental delay, especially speech delay, are prone to negative emotional behaviors.
- Mood disorder: When aggressive behaviors are persistent and associated with symptoms of sadness, this suggests a mood disorder. Young children may not necessarily report sadness. Depression may present as hyperactivity or irritability in this age group.
- Asperger's disorder, Autism or Child Disintegrative
Disorder: These disorders are typically, but not exclusively, discovered and diagnosed during the preschool years.
- Low self esteem: Children with low self esteem and/or low school affiliation are more likely to act out aggressively than those with talents and good self esteem.
- social deficits: Children who don't know how to act appropriately may instead be aggressive to engage others.
- temperament: Ask parents who the child "takes after" to elicit a description of temperament and parental projections. Check the child adjective checklist to get a sense of the parent's perception of the child's temperament or have the parents fill out a standard temperament questionnaire.
- book: Understanding Your Child's Temperament, by William B. Carey, Martha M. Jablow, C. Everett Koop, 1997, Macmillan General Reference.
- Sleep debt: Makes children vulnerable to aggressive behaviors due to the fact that they are often tired, hungry, or stressed by irregular, unusual demands.
- peer problems) all play an important
role along with environmental exposure to violence through peers, parents, media and neighborhood
influences.: Being rejected by peers early in grade school may predispose children towards aggressive behavior and later towards conduct disorder.
- suicidal or homicidal ideations/behavior. Refer immediately
for mental health services if child is judged to be immediate threat to self or others. Children who are
prone to "risk taking" may incur harm to themselves or others even when not intending it.
: Suicide accounts for 12% of mortality among adolescents in the US. Older adolescents (15-19 years) have a rate of suicide that is 8 times higher than younger adolescents (10-14 years).
- Antisocial Personality Disorder: This diagnosis cannot be given to individuals under the age of 18 years.
- Narcissistic Personality Disorder: This diagnosis cannot be given to individuals under the age of 18 years.
- Borderline Personality Disorder: This diagnosis cannot be given to individuals under the age of 18 years.
- Trigger questions: 1) What do you make of this behavior? What does your spouse make of it? 2) What is it like for you when you have to discipline ________? 3) What was it like for you when you were disciplined growing up? 4) What is it like for you when ________ is upset or frustrated? 5) What do you do when he/she does something he's not supposed to do? 6) How bad does it get? 7) Give me an example of ________'s "bad" behavior? How do you respond to the behavior? How does your partner respond?
- risk-taking behaviors: 1) If self destructive, refer immediately for mental health services. 2) Reframe such behavior as an emergency for the parent since their lack of concern is likely to have been part of the escalation of the child's actions. 3) If mainly group risk taking, end or limit. This reason should be made explicit so child will know it is done out of caring. 4) A child who does not understand risk should be evaluated for Mental Retardation, Asperger's Syndrome, or Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder.
- social skills deficits, or below
average cognitive functioning (see : Improving social skills (empathy, listening, ascribing attributions) and problem-solving (resolving conflict, communication, understanding consequences) can be done effectively through group and/or individual social skills training interventions. Comprehensive social skills programs that involve parents, are specifically geared for the age of the child, and focus on reducing aggression are most effective. For teenagers with serious conduct or antisocial problems social skills training should be conducted in conjunction with individual, family or group therapy.
- sexual activity: Query about consensual sex with peers and adults as well as possible sexual abuse -- where patient may be either victim or perpetrator or both.
- variety of
reasons.: 1. This is more common in parents who were exposed to severe punishment or violence as children, which they do not want to repeat. They may give in for a while, then have outbursts of excessive reaction which stimulate fearfulness, preemptive misbehavior, low self esteem, or aggressive behavior in their children. 2. Parents who disagree in their discipline style encourage tantrums by displaying inconsistent methods of discipline. 3. Parents may be too busy, tired or unavailable to think up or maintain consistency. 4. Parents may view their child as special and vulnerable and be uncomfortable seeing their child upset. This is most likely to occur with children who have been seriously ill, if the parents had trouble conceiving the child or if there is a history of prior abortions. The parents' inability to tolerate the child's upset and keep rules leads to the child using angry or aggressive behavior to get what they want. Some children treated as vulnerable are oppositional in order to achieve any freedom from the over protective parent. 5. One parent may feel the other is too strict and therefore be more lax than is appropriate in an attempt to counterbalance the other's discipline. 6. Parents may inappropriately under control or over control children when they react to them as though they were someone else eg a despised ex spouse or disliked aspect of themselves.
- excessive punishment: Ask for an example of the child's bad behavior and how the caregiver responded. Children who are given excessively harsh punishment or who are constantly "being yelled at" for even minor behavior issues are likely to continue the behavior when they are given no reinforcement for good behavior or as pay back to their apparently "mean" parent. Spanking or other physical punishment fosters aggression in children by modeling aggressive behavior and also by inducing pain, especially in families lacking warmth in relationships. Low self esteem from harsh punishment can also elicit aggression.
- prejudiced
parent syndrome: Parents may under control or over control children when they react to them as though they were someone else (e.g., a despised ex spouse or disliked aspect of themselves.
- inadequate attention: Children will do anything to engage caregivers including the opposite of what is asked.
- Pharmacological treatment alone: Antidepressants, lithium carbonate, carbamazepine, and propranolol are sometimes used to treat Conduct Disorder, but empirical studies proving their efficacy have not been done.
- ADHD: This is the most common co-morbid condition with Conduct Disorder. Consider using a screening questionnaire such as the Connors Rating Scale.